Friday’s post on “The Road” was originally about how puzzled I was that the book club discussion had seemed to miss the point. I could see how one person could be blinded by prose but not five. Eventually I realised “The Road” had never been a book club book. So a hastily revised version appeared on the benefits of book club discussion instead!
I can at least console myself that I’m in good company. Not only could Montaigne never remember the books he’d read he also struggled to recognise essays he had written. In an unintentional irony Will Self was on the radio this morning talking about the republication of Montaigne’s essays. Although I’m a fan you could say that Will Self has a similar problem – he sometime forgets the novels he writes have already been written. But then again “What do I know?”
Showing posts with label The Road. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Road. Show all posts
Monday, 25 January 2010
Friday, 22 January 2010
The Road
I realise I’m laying myself open to a “What have the Romans ever done for us” moment here but I’m trying to segue seamlessly into the blog entry with this so bear with me.Film adaptations are always a mistake. If you’ve seen the film versions of “Atonement”, “The Naked And The Dead” or The Human Stain you’ll know what I mean. Although there are exceptions to the rule, Burt Lancaster in “The Leopard” is a shining example, I think it’s ok as a rule of thumb. (I’d also cite Bladerunner as a counter example here but I’m sticking to book club books and, in any case, it’s a film that plays fast and loose with Philip K Dick’s Do Androids Dream Of Electric Sheep” anyway)
At a little under two hours John Hillcoat's “The Road” just falls short of being another exception. It’s a faithful recreation of the novel. It’s unremittingly bleak and at times unbearably sad movie. Not for the faint hearted, it’s particularly resonant if you have kids. It does have one advantage over the book. Although I wouldn’t have said this of the book at the time, McCarthy’s prose dominates. Or it dominated our discussion of it? Although the films fidelity to the novel is almost total it seemed to me, as a stripped down visual piece, more provocative. This might have more to do with how I read “The Road” in the first place. Perhaps, If you’re seduced by the prose you blunt it’s purpose? Maybe concentrating on the aesthetics reduces an appreciation of the moral,ethical and philosophical complexities.
Anyway this a roundabout way of saying that bookclub books benefit from the discussion. I’m reasonably certain at some stage these issues would have surfaced and the books impact would be the better for them. I'd also remember. I certainly won’t forget the conversation with Brid in a hurry. It’s not often you discuss how best to mercy-kill your children and at what point you can legitimately abandon hope. In fact, I don’t think I’ve heard Brid use the word kill so often since the time I forgot our wedding anniversary!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)