Showing posts with label The Alchemist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Alchemist. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 February 2009

The Most Divisive?

Here's a top 11 in order of divergence of opinion
(It's actually based on standard deviation of score which is probably a good enough proxy)

The Alchemist
Atonement
The Leopard
The Child That Books Built
The Bridegroom
Noughts & Crosses
London Fields
Moby-Dick
The Origin Of Species
Beloved
Layer Cake

All but two of the above are choices from over 4 years ago. This could suggest we're better able to judge a books reception. Alternatively we could all be playing safe. (Then again it could be neither. Thats Stats for you! )

My recollection is that the only books that provoked much argument / discussion were The Alchemist & Moby Dick (I think I conceded that "The Origin Of Species" was a selfish choice. I also put myself at a disadvantage defending "London Fields" since I hadn't finished re-reading it!)

And another thing..

To continue the theme I developed in an earlier post it does seem like the 'bad' books and the divisive ones are the ones we remember - The Alchemist and Moby Dick now have more mentions on this site than any other books. There are lots of books in the list to the left of this message that were very worthy, we all found them quite enjoyable and they achieved mid table respectability in our rankings, but we haven't mentioned them once on this blog. (And many of which I had completely forgotten about until I read the list again when this blog was set up).

Tuesday, 10 February 2009

The Alchemist again.....

I've not finished Kavalier and Clay, so I'll try not to look down while posting this....

In a weird kind of way, maybe the Alchemist wasn't such a bad choice after all (retrospective kudos to Simon) - if you include comments as well as main posts, it is now by a clear margin the most frequently mentioned book on this blog. What was it Oscar Wilde said was the only thing worse than being talked about?

I'll pop over to Amazon and see if they do a good deal on Katie Price's new book.

Monday, 9 February 2009

The Alchemist

I was in the Oldham branch of Waterstones on Saturday. It is only a small branch, but I would imagine it has the same special offer displays as pretty much every Waterstones up and down the country. Well, they had a selection of "Spiritual" books - I would imagine that sales of such books are positively correlated with an individual's perception of his lot during the economic crisis.

Anyway, prominent (at least in my eyes) in this display was our old friend The Alchemist. It crossed my mind to perpetrate some evil deed on these books, maybe burning them, or knocking them off the shelf, or at the very least to turn the top copy around so that nobody would be entreated to buy this drivel.

But I did nothing.... Not sure if this now makes me a part of the Coelho machine - am I responsible for the people of Oldham being subjected to this "sub-GCSE Philosophy" drivel???

Wednesday, 4 February 2009

The Hall of Shame - Bottom 10

As I said, we have now reviewed 70 books in our group. We started to assign scores out of 10 a few years ago, and then applied scores retrospectively to the whole list. Ian has produced some fantastic spreadsheets to analyse all of the information, and from this I can reveal that the current bottom 10 are as follows:

70: The Alchemist by Paulo Coelho (2.6 out of 10)
69: My Lover's Lover by Maggie O'Farrell (4.6 out of 10)
68: Noughts & Crosses by Ian Rankin (5 out of 10)
67: The Strategy Of Deception by Paul Virilio (5.4 out of 10)
66: Mr X by Peter Straub (5.8 out of 10)
65: Beloved by Toni Morrison (5.8 out of 10)
=64: This is Your Life by John O'Farrell (6 out of 10)
=65: Layer Cake by J.J Connolly (6 out of 10)
=66: I'm Not The Only One by George Galloway (6 out of 10)
=67: Teacher Man by Frank McCourt (6 out of 10)

The Alchemist is comfortably at the bottom, and my personal score awarded for this was zero out of 10, and it was lucky to get even that. I am mystified why it has sold mega millions around the globe. Anyway, I'll say no more and will reserve my bile for a future post about this abomination.

Some may find the inclusion of Beloved in the Hall of Shame, with Toni Morrison being such a revered author. I found the book okay, but the consensus was that it was a pile of cack - I paraphrase.

Any thoughts about the list, let us know!